Opinion 
 Blogs 
 National Comment 
 Big boys' greed pulls us all down 

Big boys' greed pulls us all down

If you are feeling buffeted by the global financial deep freeze, which is going to get worse before it thaws, consider the fortunes of once "Australia's richest man".

Since James Packer took control of the family corporate empire, he made a huge bet on the future of the empire. Like father like son. This is the score:

* The value of Packer's flagship company, Crown Limited, in which the Packer family has a controlling interest, has fallen from $15 a share since it was listed last year to $6.66 (the devil's number).

* Shares in Packer's billion-dollar gambling play in Macau, Melco Crown Entertainment, have gone into free-fall, dropping just over 85 per cent, from $US22 to

$US3.18, since their peak 20 months ago.

* In April Packer was offered $4.80 a share, or $3.3 billion, for the media company CMH, by another media heir, Lachlan Murdoch. Packer declined, wanting a higher price. The shares have since plunged 60 per cent, to $1.94, closing on Friday at $2.02. Almost $2 billion in value has evaporated since the bid.

* Shares in the Packer-controlled investment company Challenger Financial Services Group have fallen from $6.58 to $1.785 in the past year, a 73 per cent plunge for a company with a large number of small investors attracted by the Packer name.

* Australia's biggest mortgage fund, Challenger Howard, 20 per cent owned by Packer's CPH, suspended investor redemptions last week, freezing $2.8 billion because it said the Federal Government's pledge to guarantee bank deposits had caused a run on the fund.

* Crown's plans to build the tallest tower in Las Vegas in a multibillion-dollar casino-hotel development have been abandoned, with a $44 million write-off in development costs.

* Seek Limited, the online company in which Packer holds a 27 per cent interest, has had a run on its shares, which have fallen 40 per cent since September from $5.60 to $3.65.

Packer's net worth is now less than half what it was a year ago. His self-worth might be similar.

It could be worse. Macquarie Bank, known as "the millionaires factory" for the exorbitant rewards its executives paid themselves, was savaged for years by scathing assessments by analysts aghast at the size and secrecy of its fee structure. Now the bill has come due, paid for by its shareholders. Macquarie Group's share price has plunged 71 per cent from a peak of $98.50 last year, to $28.75 on Friday.

Even more blood has been shed at its reckless imitator, Babcock & Brown, whose market value has been destroyed since it peaked last year at $33.90. It closed at $1.40 on Friday, having lost 96 per cent of its market value and 100 per cent of its reputation.

How many little people have the big boys taken down with them? It was so easy to turn comfort into excess. At the height of the good times, the Howard-Costello government made the generous offer of allowing people to put as much as $1 million into their superannuation by June 30 last year, thus avoiding lump-sum taxes before the super rules were changed.

I was advised by a very wealthy friend to borrow the full $1 million and put it into super. The cost of servicing the debt, he said, would be covered by tax-free dividend payments, and the rising value of the super would be free money. He made it sound so simple, and inevitable, perhaps because he had done so well for so long by borrowing to the hilt.

That was 18 months ago. Since then his company has collapsed. He has sold his waterfront mansion. He has left the country, with no plans to return for the foreseeable future. I did not take his advice. I borrowed nothing. Rather than leverage up, I de-leveraged down. I have no debt, no mortgage, not even a car. What I wanted was the ultimate luxury good, something invisible but palpable - peace of mind.

Peace of mind only goes so far when you are watching the unravelling of the greatest run of gambling and speculation in human history. Like James Packer's towering ambition in Las Vegas, this gigantic global casino, in which investors bet on property, companies, commodities, currencies and derivatives, all the time, all over the world, is in the process of being wound back (perhaps to be replaced with a state-run bingo hall).

In September we were agog at giant financial houses falling like dominos. That is old news. Now it's economies, not companies, that are freezing up. The entire euro zone, the currency union of 15 advanced economies, is about to go into recession. So is the US, and Japan, our biggest export market, and Korea.

At the International Monetary Fund, countries are lining up for rescue packages, including Austria, Hungary, Ukraine, Belarus, Kazakhstan, Serbia and Pakistan. In Argentina, the Government is raiding the pension funds to find cash. The fall of the Aussie dollar has been accompanied by even more violent raids on every currency propped up by excessive foreign debt, with the conspicuous exception of the US dollar. What was supposed to stabilise the world was the "BRIC", the boom economies of Brazil, Russia, India and China, but the boom is over in Brazil, Russia is in serious trouble, India's rupee has plunged and China has gone into stress.

Amid all this, the Rudd Government, which overreacted when it committed to splurge half the budget surplus on a $10 billion stimulation package, has lowered its growth forecast for 2009 from 4 per cent to 2 per cent. That already looks optimistic. The big freeze could send growth down to zero.

Source: The Sydney Morning Herald

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1

Comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Well I am so glad that I am A poor single mum. I struggle to send my daughter to private school, but that is my only financial gift to my kids, the rest is just love. Thank you Mr Rudd because now I can pay some of next years fees and hopefully I wont fall behind. We eat well and look clean, thats life!!!
Posted by Megan on 28/10/2008 12:25:45 PM
Watching it all unfold, I feel for those 'new gamblers' who were drawn into the mix with ready access to the stock market through mum and dad investment clubs. It was all so easy. But now, what was, for them, a little bit of laughter and a flutter became the terror and the screams of the Wall St Brokers plummeting past, taking all the flutter investments with them. Scary times.
Posted by percivere on 28/10/2008 12:48:30 PM
The "little people" are all of us earning a pittance who have had our super funds ravaged. I curse all those financial gurus with high falootin degrees in economics who failed to see this coming. Morons ! May all economists rot in hell. Worse still, those stupid economists are asking us to take their advice to get us out of crisis ! What a nerve ! As for all the millionaires like young Packer : " a fool and his money are soon parted". Daddy and Grand pappy Packer are no doubt rolling in their graves ! Fools, imbeciles all !
Posted by sad sack on 28/10/2008 1:52:56 PM
The big boy's greed was the Australian Government who was turning a blind eye to what the finance market were doing in feeding the borrowing frenzy. "Honeymoon loans', "Mortgage Equity Release" to target retiree's who owned their homes the long hard way. "Instant Line-of-credit". "First Home Owners grant" (now trippled! to stimulate more debt temptation). " Fund Management Trusts". Just to keep the States in Stamp Duty taxes so the Federal Govt, can boast of a Surplus. "Our Well Regulated Banking System"- Ah! baloney. And still is with multiple business names all funded by the 'big 4'- now freezing our retiree's capital.
Posted by adaptapensioner.com on 28/10/2008 2:21:18 PM
Is money the root of all evil? Obviously it is and the greedy bastards at the top who have stomped on the little people should be living in the gutter where they belong. People should always come before money. Greed will win out in the end and destroy those who seek it. I'm happy to get by each day - as long as I have food to eat and a roof over my head I'm doing ok. Let the bastards drown but don't drag those little guy whose money you took into the water with you.
Posted by Craig Edgar on 29/10/2008 7:11:58 AM
Would more women in the boardroom change things I wonder? We can be as greedy as men, but would we inject more balance and caution if we indeed take less risk? We get paid less anyway. Sadly, behaving like one of the boys appears to be the only way to get ahead. See: http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2008/10/28/2403572.htm
Posted by Rigmarole on 29/10/2008 9:40:59 AM
financial advisors are a waste of time and space. Do it yourself!
Posted by geff on 29/10/2008 11:17:57 AM
Sad Sack, I'm an economist with a family SMSF, who went 100% cash late Sept 08...now capital 100% intact earning 8.3% for the 2 years in a bank now guaranteed by the Govt for the next 3 years for free! This crash was as obvious as knowing that what goes up always goes down, it wasn't economics but greed that blinded the rest of my economist colleagues. As my labourer Dad always said "Cash is king"...and certainly for the next couple of years!! Go cash in a bank asap, my friend.
Posted by happy economist on 30/10/2008 10:02:23 AM
It's all called greed, even now, when things are tough, they are still panicking and pulling the noose tighter around their wealthy little necks. To those who borrowed to invest in shares, 'penny pinchers, pound losers'. Whatever happened to that,'don't put your eggs in one basket'? Did You???? At the end of the day, the higher you are, the bigger the fall, I won't be falling too far, just a little hard. But we're all in the same boat, let's just pull together
Posted by Mamamia on 30/10/2008 12:01:17 PM
A few comments. 1. I am have a degree in economics and have been telling my family and friends for months to expect a downturn. It's called "economic cycle". There has to be busts with the booms, otherwise it would be all boom until no-one could afford anything. 2. The banks havent frozen the retirees capital. It is investments trusts and managed funds, which thanks to the governments bank deposit convenant have left them no choice. With investors leaving in drove to move to the "Cash is King" environment where bank deposits are protected, what other options did they have? There is only a certain amount of liquidity in these funds, especially property trusts. There is more to the issue than just "not being able to get my money." If they werent frozen, then you could almost guarantee there would be none left pretty soon anyway. 3. I'm not too sure how a "poor single mum" can afford to send her kids to private school. I was educated through our public school system, when to uni, and I'm still paying off my HECS debt almost 10 years later. My parents did as much as they could financially for me, but to cry poor when you can still pay ridiculous fees for a private school is a little rich. 4. If I had any cash (which I dont, not due to being washed in debt, but cos Im not one of the people eligible for any government assistance or Christmas bonuses) I would be investing like crazy. Now is the time to get INTO the market not OUT. Sure, the market is still likely to drop, but how far and for how long we cannot predict, but if you are investing in shares or super generally these should be long term investments and in the long run it will be a boost to your wealth. I'll get off my soapbox now.
Posted by Mrs Economics on 30/10/2008 1:36:10 PM
1 | 2  |  next >

Post A Comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
National Comment
Here is the place for you to vent on any national or world news and lifestyle stories on the YourGuide websites. If there is anything you see or hear that you like or don't like, tell us. Don't keep it to yourself!
Michael Mucci illustration
Michael Mucci illustration

16/12/2008 | So we now have desperate parents attempting to bribe teachers to get their children into a selective high school. What a sad indictment of our education policies, the holy grail of which is parental choice.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...